Pizza restaurants

Pappas Pizzeria

4.0 361 reviews 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM 460 S County Line Dr, Chaparral, NM 88081, United States

Discover this place

Pappas Pizzeria, located in Chaparral, NM, has garnered a loyal following for its delicious offerings and inviting atmosphere. Customers rave about the perfect pizza crust, which many describe as the highlight of their experience. One enthusiastic reviewer even recommended it to friends from El Paso, emphasizing that Pappas serves pizza that rivals the best from New York.

The wings at Pappas Pizzeria deserve special mention as well. Flavors like spicy lemon pepper and garlic Parmesan have impressed patrons time and time again. One diner mentioned that both bone-in and boneless wings were outstanding, leaving a lasting impression with their taste and texture.

While the cheese bread received mixed reviews, the satisfaction with calzones and the overall value make Pappas a go-to spot. A customer expressed sheer delight over the delivery quality and presentation, noting that the calzones were cooked to crispy perfection. With personalized customer service and a keen attention to detail, Pappas Pizzeria stands out as a cherished local eatery, ensuring every visit leaves customers craving more.

With fair prices and an unwavering commitment to quality, Pappas Pizzeria truly embodies the spirit of a family-run establishment that feels like home.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pappas Pizzeria before visiting.

Reviews for Pappas Pizzeria

4.0

361 reviews

100%

27%

13%

25%

Review highlights

Based on 361 reviews

Pappas Pizzeria in Chaparral, NM, consistently receives praise for its flavorful and well-prepared menu offerings, particularly the pizza and wings. Reviewers frequently highlight the quality of the crust, describing it as a standout feature, alongside generous and well-balanced toppings. The wings, especially the spicy lemon pepper and garlic Parmesan varieties, are commonly mentioned as a customer favorite. Service at Pappas Pizzeria is generally described as friendly and personalized, contributing to a neighborhood feel reminiscent of family-owned pizzerias. While the food quality and taste are widely appreciated, some feedback points to occasional delays in order acknowledgment or pickup. Pricing is noted as fair, supporting the overall positive dining experience. The combination of consistent food quality, inviting atmosphere, and attentive service makes Pappas Pizzeria a recommended choice for locals and visitors alike.

Expedition Kitchen

Jun 20, 2025

Wings were great, both the bone in and boneless. We ordered spicy lemon pepper, man was that good, and the garlic Parmesan did not disappoint. The pizza crust was perfect and the amount of toppings were pleasing. The cheese bread however left me wanting more. Price was very fair, the only drawback I could see was how long it took for someone to realize I was in the lobby waiting for my order.

itsirma

Jun 04, 2025

I ordered a Calzone and spicy lemon pepper wings for my partner for delivery, and it was was the perfect order, perfect in presentation in taste he couldn’t believe it. We order here all the time and it’s never been this perfect, he even called back to thank the person that made it. They used the appropriate amount of ingredients cooked it enough that it was crispy , and seasoned on top of the calzone, he says the wings were great the texture was better than usual and it was the first time he tried the spicy lemon pepper, Pretty much the only pizza place in town, and it’s been great lately! The calzones are my favorite. The delivery guy called when we was outside for delivery.

Qeso Yo

May 10, 2025

Lov this place, the pizza is delicious, great service, 100% recommend

Ha Ha

May 03, 2025

Their pizza is for real fantastic only crust I’ve ever looked forward to eating . I tell people from El Paso they need to come try it !

William Beschle

Apr 27, 2025

Papa's Pizza reminds me of the family owned businesses in the New York area. The pizza is great and the service is personalized. Drive to El Paso if you must, but Papa's is great pizza in our home town.

Angel Perez Lopez

Mar 29, 2025

They delivered to Chaparral and that's the greatest reason why I like this place and its food Bro I can't with the food it's sooooo good ( it was one pizza but next time I would get two)

girona022

Mar 25, 2025

The food is exceptional and very good but just from that notion people will automatically assume they have the same service as dominos or Papa John's they do not, it is a locally own pizza place, if you want great customer service where you feel superior then go to a Domino's, Papa John's, little ceaser.

N W Fortitude

Mar 08, 2025

When it comes to pizza, if the crust doesn't satisfy, then the meal isn't fit to eat. Now Pappas uses a gad oven and always cooks the pizza so that a traditional crust is well toasted around the edges and the bottom but still moist enough to enjoy the entire experience. Even with leftovers, the next day, it still satisfies. Also, the Garlic Parmesan wings are great.